|
Gwendolyn Hyslop
University of Oregon and The Aienla Project

Northeast India is well-known for its incredible linguistic and cultural diversity. In the state of Arunachal Pradesh alone, 26 tribes are identified by the Indian government. But the actual number of languages spoken in Arunachal Pradesh is much grater. One of the cultural groups in Tawang and West Kameng in Arunachal Pradesh identifies itself as ‘Monpa’. In 2007 I traveled through West Kameng and Tawang district in Arunachal Pradesh and studied a little bit of some of the different ‘Monpa’ languages. The Monpa language of Bomdila is also called Tshangla by foreign linguists (e.g. Andvik 1999). In addition to being spoken in Bomdila, Tshangla is spoken by approximately 138,000 people in eastern Bhutan (van Driem 1998).

Bomdila in February 2007

Lobsang, Koncho, Tashi and Thupten in Bomdila, who helped me learn some Tshangla
The Monpa language of Tawang is quite different from Tshangla. Linguists refer to Tawang Monpa as Dakpa and state that it belongs to the East Bodish (Shafer 1954) family of Tibeto-Burman, as opposed to Tshangla, which is a Bodic branch in and of itself within Tibeto-Burman (e.g. Bradley 1997). Dakpa is also spoken in Bhutan and Tibet.

Me, Thupten Norbu and Tawang Language Officer Ngawang Lamsang in Lhou village, Tawang

Karma Tshering putting a microphone on storyteller Pema Gombu

In the Sumo en route to Tawang
The Monpa language of Dirang is again reported to be a distinct language. George van Driem (2001) identifies Dirang Monpa as Lishpa. Unfortunately, I didn’t get the opportunity to meet anyone who spoke Lishpa. Perhaps in my next trip to Arunachal Pradesh I shall be so lucky! To help illustrate the differences between Tshangla (Bomdila or ‘Central’ Monpa) and Dakpa (Tawang, or ‘Northern’ Monpa), I have compiled a small table comparing some words from both languages based on what I learned in my 2007 trip. The Tshangla and Dakpa data are written using characters from the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA). Even if one does not know the IPA the point that the languages are different should be quite clear.
References Andvik, Erik.1999. Tshangla grammar. Eugene, Oregon: University of Oregon PhD Dissertation. Bradley, David. 1997. Tibeto-Burman Languages and Classification. In David Bradley, ed., Papers in Southeast Asian Linguistics No 14: Tibeto-Burman Languages of the Himalayas. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics. van Driem, George. 1998. Dzongkha. Leiden: Research School CNWS. Shafer, Robert. 1954. The Linguistic Position of Dwags. Oriens, Zeitschrift der Internationalen Gesellschraft für Orientforschung 7: 348-356 |